Wednesday, January 28, 2009

When Life Begins

I will start by saying I don't know. But I do have an opinion on when it doesn't.

There is nothing special about a fertilized egg. Many see this potential for life as wonderful and miraculous and deserving of protection, and it is wonderful. But is it deserving of protection? I do not think so, because the mother's body does not necessarily protect it. The majority (65% to 80%) of fertilized eggs do not adhere to the uterine wall and are flushed out by the mother. Furthermore, many anomalies occur which are contrary to a life-at-conception argument. Identical twins occur when a fertilized egg splits into two. Did both lives start when the egg was fertilized? Or does a second one start when it splits? Which egg retains the first life? Or do two lives begin when it splits? But an egg could split further and the same dilemma is presented. Furthermore, the eggs can split, and then resolve into one again. Was there two lives, or just one? It seems hard to say that life begins at conception without having a loose conception of life. I feel a more appropriate definition to still err on the side of caution is when a blastocyst adheres to the uterine wall. This is after 12-14 days and the likelihood is this egg will cause a pregnant mother.

This position of an operating definition for life is tenuous and not something I believe in strongly. I do believe that prior to this adherence to the uterine wall, the blastocyst is not life.

Universal Healthcare

Universal Healthcare

This is something I strongly believe in. It starts with my belief of equal opportunity. Part of equal opportunity extends to everyone having equal rights to live, and by extension, be healthy. Having a system in place where we have to pay for our right to live is by my definitions not respecting people's rights. Hence, everyone has a right to healthcare.

This is a strong statement. Often people read it as a general statement, but it is intentionally strong. If universal healthcare is provided by the government, then part of one's taxes will go towards healthcare. People often extend this to say that taxpayers pay for their healthcare, and therefore there should be universal healthcare for taxpayers. But I specifically meant it to be more general. I believe even non-taxpayers deserve it. It is a basic right, and just because they may have compromised others' rights of liberty (by not paying equal taxes, hence there is inequality and therefore liberty is compromised), they still deserve their right to healthcare. This is because of my order of rights, that life is above liberty. And therefore universal healthcare is a basic human right.

Gay Marriage

This "issue" to me is clear cut. There should be no controversy. Gay marriage should be legalized, across the entire country (I live in the US), immediately.

My argument for gay marriage is quite simple. I believe in the rights of humans for liberty and equality of that liberty, and therefore there should not be a legal government action that is only for a certain type of people. Namely, homosexuals deserve the same rights as heterosexuals.

This argument is not sufficient for some, and they raise some objections. Usually along the lines of:
• "Marriage is between a man and a woman"
If this is so, then it should not be a legal state of being between two people, as it is discriminatory. Also, the basis for this statement is generally religious texts, which should have no effect on law.
• "Gay Marriage will weaken the family"
So does divorce. I see no reason why this should even be considered an argument. The law's job is not to encourage a lifestyle for its populace, especially at the cost of individual's rights.
• "They should only have civil unions, and not be able to force marriage upon churches."
I don't believe they should force marriage upon churches either. No one does, anyway. Marriages are legally started in courthouses. As for civil unions being an alternate term that has the same benefits, nice try, but I don't believe in separate but equal.

I don't care if people think that marriage is an institution that must be protected. A society and government's job is to protect its citizens' rights above all others. And it is a discriminatory institution if it for a man and a woman, as described above. If we have true separation of church and state, gay marriage should be legal everywhere.

Equal Opportunity

Equal opportunity is the right of every individual to have the option and availability to do whatever he would like to do with his life free of oppression or resistance. This is excluding those actions that compromise others' rights. This means that there should be no obstacle, in a just society, that prevents any one from attaining any station in life that he so desires beyond his own free will and others' free will. This is derivative of the right to liberty, as only with equal opportunity does one have actual free will to do what they desire to do in life.

Classic examples of obstacles to equal opportunity are education, and discrimination, and they often work together. Education is a right (right to knowledge as a liberty), and different quality education is available in different areas. This disparity is unfair. Furthermore, since school funding is generally linked to property taxes, this amounts to money deciding the quality of one's education. This is patently unfair.

Discrimination prevents people from attaining a station they desire because of prejudice against a quality that is unrelated to the station. This is also clearly unjust. However, it may be a right under liberty. More clarification and thought is needed.

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Abortion

This is an issue of which I have not formed a definitive opinion. I feel, as stated before, that the right of life is higher than the right of liberty. The liberty of the woman I feel is of secondary importance to the life of the fetus. No one in science can isolate when a fetus or blastocyst achieves sentience, and thus, we do not now when there is life. To err on the side of caution is to not abort since it is not known if there is life in the womb. However, there is more detail required that amends my viewpoint.

To me, there is not life at conception. This is my view on the beginning of life. Therefore, under this definition, the morning after pill is not murder.

But after this 12-14 day period is abortion murder? I don't know. To err on the side of caution is not to risk murder merely for your liberty (as I view life above liberty). Therefore I believe it safest to carry out the pregnancy. Adoption is always there as an option for those who still don't feel capable of raising the baby. Budgetary issues are unimportant as one cannot put a dollar value on life.

There are further exceptions, however. I support abortion in the case of rape. This is due to the forced responsibility that I believe is unfair. In cases of consensual sex, the mother and father agreed to take the risk of pregnancy, and the fetus is their responsibility. However, in the case of rape, the rapist forces this responsibility upon the mother. I do not believe such a heinous act of violation of liberty can transfer responsibility to the victim. Therefore the responsibility of the baby lies with the rapist and the mother is not obligated to have the baby. This viewpoint of mine is still being pondered, in terms of degrees. For example, the effect of how old the fetus is, if any, and other considerations.

Another possible exception is the health of the mother. As stated before, life is the highest right. Therefore it is reasonable to consider the morality of abortion in the case of possible health concerns for the mother. Part of the right to liberty includes equality; All moral persons' lives are equal and none is more valuable than a different one. (Link to equality as a part of liberty) So the right of the fetus to live is equal the right of the mother's. However, it is still in question whether the fetus is alive. This factor makes me undecided on this case. It will require more thought and I can conclude nothing about this exception.

Assumptions

These assumptions are not necessarily a priori, or independent of experience, but things that I see as true. The arguments here on in depend on these.

  • Humans have rights merely because of their existence. These rights can be briefly described as:
    • Life
    • Liberty (and with it the right of free speech, equal opportunity)

Furthermore, all humans have equal claim to these rights. This list of rights may seem short, but many more

specific rights are under these more general rights, and the rationale for the more specific ones will be given in

terms of these if necessary. These rights are in order. To me, life is of higher value than liberty. This is because

one can restore liberties, but not life.


These rights are only to be taken away if one has compromised another's rights.


More to be added.